Police Secrets, Breathalyzer Records and a Hidden Conflict of Interest

What happens when police withhold information that could affect the fairness of an impaired driving investigation? In Episode 478 of Driving Law, Kyla Lee and Paul Doroshenko examine two troubling disclosure issues: Vancouver Police Department’s refusal to release records concerning BC’s new roadside breathalyzer and a Manitoba case involving an undisclosed relationship between a police officer and a key witness.

Kyla discusses her freedom of information request for training and technical records relating to the Dräger Alcotest 6000. The Vancouver Police Department has withheld several documents after the manufacturer objected to disclosure on commercial confidentiality grounds. Kyla and Paul question whether those objections justify keeping information about police training and device performance from public scrutiny, particularly when the equipment is used to enforce impaired driving laws.

The conversation then turns to a Manitoba impaired driving case in which an officer failed to disclose his romantic relationship with a nurse whose information helped support a production order for hospital records. The relationship came to light by chance after the accused had pleaded guilty, and the court ultimately found that the misconduct warranted a stay of proceedings. Kyla and Paul discuss why full and frank disclosure is essential to the integrity of judicial authorizations.

They also examine BC’s new cabinet appointments and their potential implications for ICBC and public safety. This week’s Ridiculous Driver of the Week involves a stolen excavator allegedly used to ram police vehicles in Airdrie, Alberta.

Scroll to Top
CALL ME NOW