This is a really common explanation for why people have their cell phone in their hand when stopped by police. A lot of people think that they cannot be ticketed for using a cell phone while driving if they are not actually using any of the cellular or internet services. This is a common misconception.
The Motor Vehicle Act sections on cell phone use set out very clearly what it means to be using a phone while driving. Use is a term defined in the Act to mean one of four things: holding the device in a position in which it may be used; operating one or more of the device’s functions; communicating orally with another person; or watching the screen of the device. It’s tough to find, but you have to look at the Use of Electronic Devices While Driving Regulation in order to learn all the definitions of use. Operating the functions of the device includes changing the music. And you are also required to hold the device in a manner in which it may be used to change the music.
If you are using a hand-held audio device, it has to be securely affixed to the vehicle and transmitting the music through the vehicle’s speakers in order to be lawful. So even if you are changing the music on your iPod, and not an iPhone, if you’re holding it in your hand or playing using the device’s speakers you are violating the law.
I wasn’t holding a phone, it was my wallet
My reaction to this defence has always been something akin to this. It just doesn’t work. It raises the obvious question of “why the heck would anyone drive around with their wallet held to their face and their mouth moving?” It is completely unbelievable. Unless you were actually holding your wallet to your face, I’d recommend not advancing this argument. You’ll be laughed out of court.
Don’t believe me? Well, there’s a reported decision involving a man who actually tried to make this pitch to the Justice of the Peace. This was what she ultimately ruled upon hearing the argument:
Finally, although this of lesser consideration in my decision than what I have recited above, I would estimate that I have heard the same explanation from male drivers at least a dozen times in the past couple of years and am somewhat skeptical when I hear this defence from male drivers who claim they were holding their wallet to their ear. It is a practice that holds no logic.
And I think she is absolutely right to have come to that conclusion. This common explanation is without merit, and will not result in an acquittal in traffic court.
It wasn’t a phone but an iPod or something else
All drivers should spend some time reading the electronic device regulations in order to understand what electronic devices are prescribed by the law. The definition is very broad. All handheld devices that have a hands-free function fall under the definition, as do GPS devices, any device that can compute data (yes, this could mean a calculator), hand-held audio players, hand microphones, and televisions.
The idea of proving that a cell phone is a cell phone and not a calculator or some other piece of electronics was discussed in a case called R. v. Schull. There, the lawyer for Mr. Schull had argued the officer had to establish it was a cell phone. The Court considered the regulations and determined that so long as it was an electronic device, it was unnecessary to prove which subsection it fell under. Mr. Schull was convicted. You’ll note there is also a funny quote from an Ontario case about how stupid it is to suggest someone is driving around, talking, with an object held to their face.
So if you’re planning to argue that your electronic device was not a cell phone, you have to be familiar with the broad nature of the definition. The “It was an iPod” excuse does not and cannot work under the law.
It was in my cupholder/on my lap
Many people are unaware that hands-free devices cannot simply be sitting loose in the vehicle. GPS devices, cell phones with bluetooth, and other devices must be mounted. Cell phones, pursuant to the Regulations, must be securely installed on the vehicle or the driver’s person, within easy reach of the driver’s seat, and must require only one touch to begin or end a call. Earpieces may only be worn in one ear.
I’ve also seen lots of cases where people argue that they were “hands-free” because the phone was tucked under a hat, tucked into a hijab, niqab, or turban, or somehow wedged into the driver’s clothing. That does not meet the definition of “securely installed” as contemplated by the Motor Vehicle Act.
I see the police driving with their cell phones all the time
This doesn’t matter. There are exceptions in the Motor Vehicle Act to people who are bound by cell phone laws. Police officers, paramedics, and firefighters are all exempt from the prohibition against using their cell phones, provided they are engaged in their work-related duties. And there are valid reasons for these exemptions. Emergency personnel need to be able to quickly respond to situations, and can sometimes be on the phone with other members or victims getting a moment-by-moment update on situations.
The police and other emergency personnel are not allowed to be using their cell phones to have personal conversations while driving, and the hope is that they will follow these regulations. They are not above the law, but fall under the law as an exempted class of people because of the nature of their work.
It’s no more dangerous than if I were reading a book
Yup, and you shouldn’t read a book behind the wheel either. While there are no provisions in the Motor Vehicle Act that address reading books while driving, this compelling piece from SenseBC outlines some of the ways in which this type of behaviour has always been covered by existing traffic laws. There are provisions like driving without due care and attention and driving without reasonable consideration that would encapsulate someone foolish enough to read a book while driving.
It’s also arguable that reading a book while driving meets the definition for the criminal offence of dangerous driving. The standard that the Crown has to prove for dangerous driving is that the driving was a marked departure from the standard an ordinary driver would use. I cannot see why any ordinary driver would think it sensible to read a book while driving (though if you ask me about some of my teenage driving habits, I’d have to admit to this one) and so I think the conviction could be made out on that basis.
And, yes, you will be ticketed and mocked if you read a book while driving.
I have an “N” and I didn’t know I couldn’t use a phone at all
Ignorance of the law is no excuse. If you engage in a regulated activity, such as driving, and you are licensed to do so, you are expected and presumed in law to be aware of the conditions of your license. There is one particular Justice of the Peace in the Vancouver traffic courts who will quiz Class 7 drivers (N drivers) on the conditions of their license before they leave court. You do not want to be the person who forgets their conditions.
It’s also pretty difficult to argue that you do not know the conditions of your license when they are printed on the back of it.
I was stopped and not moving
The provisions of the Motor Vehicle Act that apply to cell phone use are not limited to when you are actively driving the vehicle. You can only use the electronic device if you are lawfully parked off the roadway, or lawfully parked on the roadway and not impeding traffic. This means that if you are at a red light, you cannot use your cell phone.
Someone recently asked me about why there were prohibitions against using electronic devices at red lights, since you aren’t engaged in operating the vehicle. I explained that the obvious reason for this is the risk created by a vehicle stopped at a red light not paying attention when it turns green. It creates a greater risk for traffic behind to rear-end the stopped vehicle or another vehicle. It also creates a risk that a left-turning car will decide to proceed and the stopped vehicle suddenly begin to drive, causing a collision. You need to be watching an intersection when you are stopped in order to make assessments of when it is safe to enter the intersection. You cannot do that if your attention is focussed on a cell phone or other electronic device in your vehicle.
So if I get a cell phone ticket, am I screwed?
Absolutely not. An experienced and knowledgeable traffic court lawyer will not advance pointless arguments. There are defences to cell phone and electronic device tickets, and there are ways to attack the reliability of the officer’s observations in a smart fashion. I have successfully resolved countless tickets, including electronic device tickets, for my clients and am happy to talk to you about your case. So give me a call and we can talk about how I can help you defend yourself in court.
I will not, however, run an argument that you were just having a quick chat with your wallet.
I just received a ticket for using hand held devise, today July 15 / 06. I was not using phone. I was on my way to gym drinking protein shake. Phone was not even readily accessible. Ironically when police came to car window,my Bluetooth hands free system started ringing and I took phone out of pants to show that phone auto directs everything through hands free system. He also said that he could see me reaching into my pockets after I pulled over. Of course I was, I was looking for my drivers licence! After issuing ticket, he pointed out that my phone (in belt)was now slightly over seat belt, meaning I used it while driving… but he knew I just had it out to show police that I couldn’t a cept incoming calls! Please help defend bogus ticket…
Hello, tender thanks you looking for tidings! I repost in Facebook
Hello, recognition you in regard to information! how long does viagra last http://viapwronline.com I repost in Facebook.
viagra online pharmacy
Hello, rebuke you http://cialisxtl.com in spite of phrase! cialis prices
viagra side effects
Cialis warnings for cialis cialis for peyronie
Great internet website! It looks extremely good! Maintain the excellent job!
http://fr.t-booster2020.com/
Cialis fda warning list cialis $200 cialis coupon
de testosteron
I treasure the knowledge on your web site. Thanks a lot.
testosteron booster werkt het
Good web page you’ve here.
http://fr.musclemass.space/meilleur-creatine-pour-musculation/
You have got amazing stuff right here.
increase testosterone supplements
Pretty educational….looking forth to returning.
http://fr.testosteron.space/aliment-riche-en-testosterone/
You’ve incredible information right.
http://es.cgtribc.org/eliminacion-de-toxinas/
Wow cuz this is excellent job! Congrats and keep it up.
What’s happening, tidy website you have going here. http://baraita.net/the-best-products-for-baldness-and-hair-loss/
You’ve gotten one of the better sites. http://baraita.net/which-diet-pills-are-effective-and-which-are-not/
Love the site– very individual pleasant and great deals to see! http://baraita.net/how-to-delay-ejaculation/
Passion the site– really individual friendly and lots to see! http://machinalansu.pl/ekstender-ekstenderowi-nie-rowny/
Cialis buy viagra cialis purchasing cialis on the internet
Many thanks, this site is extremely handy. http://machinalansu.pl/naturalne-sposoby-na-walke-z-tradzikiem/
Thank you so much! This is definitely an fantastic online site. http://baraita.net/are-acne-pills-a-good-choice/
Keep up the awesome work !! Lovin’ it! http://machinalansu.pl/laserowe-usuwanie-tradziku/
Maintain the exceptional job !! Lovin’ it! http://baraita.net/penis-pumps-and-extenders/
You’re an extremely valuable web site; could not make it without ya! http://baraita.net/proven-methods-for-cellulite/
Great looking site. Think you did a great deal of your very own coding. http://machinalansu.pl/laserowe-usuwanie-tradziku/
Passion the website– very user friendly and whole lots to see! http://baraita.net/pills-for-muscle-growth-and-muscle-mass/
Great looking site. Suppose you did a classify of your own html coding. http://nl.testosteron.space/tekort-testosteron/
The information is very salutary. best detox drink
Various thanks, this placement is danged on. fresh health detox amsterdam
You have superb matter at this point. 7 weken zwanger symptomen tweeling
Thanks really adept. Purposefulness certainly share locale with my friends. http://fr.detoxyn.org/detoxification-7-days/
You’re an to the nth degree practical internet orientation; couldn’t acquire it without ya! impotenz hilfe
Acknowledge up the caring matter and delivering in the accumulation! http://fr.cgtribc.org/detoxification-foie-alcool/
Numberless thanks on sharing this distant web-site. produit pour allonger la verge
recognition so a consignment on your internet locate it helps a uncut lot. http://it.t-booster.org/cos'e-il-testosterone/
Passion the install– bloody individual friendly and great deals to envision! http://nnet.it/allungare-il-pipino/
I appreciate reading inclusive of your websites. Thank you so much! http://newtargetgroup.it/come-salvare-un-pennello-su-photoshop/
Great looking spot. Ruminate over you did a inordinate apportion of your own coding. disintossicazione cellulare
Keep up the massive job and generating the drive! metodo naturale allungamento pene
I like this website – its so usefull and helpfull. excès de testostĂ©rone chez l’homme
Amazing….such a valuable milieu. dieta disintossicante senza nichel
Horrifying web-site you get contemporary here. http://bloggg.org/porcentaje-masa-muscular-hombre/
Thanks a end! This is certainly an amazing internet locality! disintossicazione ludopatia
Wow, smashing portal. Thnx … testostĂ©rone agressivitĂ©
Hi there, practised webpage you must got affluent here. http://newtargetgroup.it/piselli-in-umido-bimby/
Respect it on sharing this well-ordered website. zeolith entgiftung nebenwirkungen
Thanks a great deal b much! This is unequivocally an passionate online plat. http://fr.cgtribc.org/m'lis-detoxification-rejuvenating-body-cleanse/
With thanks in the interest of sharing your visionary website. aumento dimensioni pene
Cialis taking l-citrulline and cialis together interactions for cialis
Valuable it! It a marvellous plot. detox ontlasting
You play a joke on astonishing intelligence on this website. http://nl.musclemass.space/spiergroei-per-maand/
Continue the close form and producing in the drive! fare palestra aumenta il testosterone
Positively….such a costly internet place. http://nl.global-box.net/ayurveda-detox/
Wow because this is stupendous job! Congrats and take care it up. http://newtargetgroup.it/come-faccio-a-stimolare-la-crescita-del-seno/
In point of fact, such a handy web epoch. tan veloz como el deseo analisis
Provide for up the surprising agitate !! Lovin’ it! zone erogene uomo cancro
Fanciful website you’ve gotten here. http://nl.global-box.net/ontgiftingsverschijnselen-detox/
Keep up the notable appointment !! Lovin’ it! http://mts47.fr/pasion-y-deseo/
Astounding area you’ve gotten contemporary here. http://it.global-box.net/tempo-di-disintossicazione-da-fumo/
I love looking at your website. With thanks! http://it.global-box.net/dieta-disintossicante-senza-glutine-e-lattosio/
Keep going the useful work and generating the claque! http://portassicurazioni.it/esercizi-di-allungamento-cosce/
You’ve the most impressive cobweb pages. http://it.musclemass.space/aumento-massa-muscolare-donne/
Thanks meant as a replacement for giving numberless of these danged proper rationale matter.
http://newtargetgroup.it/integratori-per-ricrescita-capelli/
Self-controlled spider’s web page you’ve flourishing here. http://nl.t-booster2020.com/testosteron-pleisters-kopen/
Thanks, this locale is really helpful. testosterone sigla
Uncommonly peculiar gratifying placement. Enormous communication unhesitatingly readily obtainable on handful gos to. dieta disintossicante al nichel
Keep up the practical occupation and generating the bunch! médicament pour érection
a cheap viagra canadian pharmacy viagra buy viagra from canada
how to get viagra without a doctor buy cheap cialis australia viagra canada
buy cialis online legal viagra sale europe blood pressure pills cialis
Le hará un descuento del desplazamiento cuando se lleve a cabo la reparación.Si decide no hacer la reparación de su nevera ya que puede que no tenga solución la reparación, entonces el técnico le ofrecería otro electrodoméstico de igual mayor calidad con un significativo descuento, y en otro caso solo se cobraría el desplazamiento a su domicilio, quedando siempre pendiente que si nos vuelve a llamar se le descuenta dicho desplazamiento.
Una presión que tiende a expulsar el agua que ha quedado en el interior del circuito, actuando, al mismo tiempo, como efecto limpiador y de precalentamiento. Hola, Ferran, agradecemos tu paciencia y lamentamos tener que indicarte que deberás llevar tu cafetera a nuestro Servicio Técnico Oficial porque podría tener un problema en el termostato. Hola de nuevo y gracias por la rapidez en el envío del manual solicitado para mi cafetera M590 captain express. Me podrías decir el motivo el porqué no hay venta de recambios y accesorios en la web oficial de las cafeteras.
Reparacion urgente de lavadoras en Madrid, servicio técnico ofrecido por la empresa Abeto Hogar S.L., contamos con un servicio urgente de reparacion de lavadoras, todos sabemos el contratiempo que causa que cualquier electrodoméstico se averíe, pero cuando se trata de la lavadora nos parece que la suciedad ha invadido la vivienda y no hay nada en ese momento mas importante que reparar la lavadora.
Reparación Frigoríficos Alcobendas, Servicio técnico de reparación frigoríficos Alcobendas está especializado en solucionar todas las averías que se presenten, tales como: No enciende el frigorífico, no enfría la nevera, hace mucho ruido la nevera, congela, botonera mal, hace mucha escarcha el frigorífico, enfría demasiado, carga de gas, no cierra herméticamente, se sale el agua.