Immediate Roadside Prohibition for DUI: Success Rates and Statistics

If you read my firm’s blog, you’ve probably read that we are consistently the top law firm in British Columbia for Immediate Roadside Prohibition for DUI cases. I wanted to write a short post breaking down some of the statistics over the past few months, so that people can better see the success that our firm has had, and in particular the success that I have had in defending these cases.

Frequently, clients who phone ask me who the best lawyers are to defend Immediate Roadside Prohibition cases. It’s not uncommon for people to want to shop around to find the best person, at the right price. I wish that I could answer these clients with the statistical information, but it’s impossible to do a hyperlink over the phone. So I’m providing the information here.

What numbers are we looking at anyway?
Breaking down the statistics from the past six months is likely the most relevant. So I’m looking at IRP review cases from May, June, July, August, September, and October 2015. For the months of June, July, and August, 2015 the winning cases were published on the BC Government’s Open Information Website after a Freedom of Information request made by a member of the media. The numbers from May, September, and October were obtained by Freedom of Information requests made by my office. The BC Government deliberately leaves in our client information so that the decisions cannot be published on the Open Information website. My suspicion is that they are embarrassed by how many IRP cases are won by me and other lawyers from our office. But all this information can be verified by making an identical request, if you have doubts about its veracity.

How many IRPs were issued in each month?
Each month had roughly the same number of IRPs iss_ued, and roughly the same number of hearings conducted. There were slightly more in the summer months which is consistent with my experience. People are out more in the summer, and so the drinking and driving numbers tend to rise. There is also typically a spike in the number of IRPs issued at Christmas time. October is usually the month with the fewest number of IRPs issued.

The breakdowns for each month are as follows:

  • May: 1561 Immediate Roadside Prohibitions issued
  • June: 1328 Immediate Roadside Prohibitions issued
  • July: 1499 Immediate Roadside Prohibitions issued
  • August: 1478 Immediate Roadside Prohibitions issued
  • September: 1249 Immediate Roadside Prohibitions issued
  • October: 1347 Immediate Roadside Prohibitions issued

This represents the total number issued by police, regardless of whether they were for refusing to blow, for blowing a “Fail” or for blowing a “Warn” reading. This means that in a six-month period, police in British Columbia issued 8,462 Immediate Roadside Prohibitions. When you factor in the number of investigations which resulted in a criminal charge for impaired driving, or a 24-Hour Prohibition for alcohol or drugs, there were likely more than ten thousand separate impaired driving investigations during this six-month time period.

How many IRPs were disputed and how many were revoked?
I also managed to obtain the numbers that show how many IRPs were disputed in each month, and the total number that were revoked. Again, you’ll see a spike in the summer months. This is in part due to an increase in the number of cases, but also due to an argument that I discovered that led to hundreds of Immediate Roadside Prohibitions being revoked for improper calibration procedures. The evidence on that issue has now changed, but that’s a whole other blog post and an issue that’s headed to BC Supreme Court soon.

The breakdowns for disputes each month look like this:

  • May: 264 review hearings conducted, 94 Immediate Roadside Prohibitions revoked
  • June: 272 review hearings conducted, 128 Immediate Roadside Prohibitions revoked
  • July: 365 review hearings conducted, 164 Immediate Roadside Prohibitions revoked
  • August: 301 review hearings conducted, 109 Immediate Roadside Prohibitions revoked
  • September: 229 review hearings conducted, 84 Immediate Roadside Prohibitions revoked
  • October: 232 review hearings conducted, 80 Immediate Roadside Prohibitions revoked.

These numbers are all the review hearings conducted by all lawyers and self-represented parties in each month. This means that the success rate remained consistent at between 35%-45% for those months. These numbers are surprising, given how few Immediate Roadside Prohibitions are disputed overall. If you do the math, you can see that roughly 20% of people issued an Immediate Roadside Prohibition will dispute it. But with success rates at around 40% for those that do dispute it (regardless of whether they have a lawyer) then the chances of success are greater than the Government would have you think.

Imagine if the remaining 80% of people who were issued IRPs bothered to dispute them. There might be more IRPs revoked each month, assuming the success rate stays the same. It’s also something that raises significant questions about the effectiveness of the IRP scheme itself. If 40% of those disputed are revoked, then it’s reasonable to assume 40% overall would be revoked. All of a sudden, the IRP law seems less valuable and more frightening. Imagine – if you got pulled over and investigated by police for drinking and driving, there is a 40% chance the police did it wrong.

That’s not the type of policing we expect in a free and democratic society. And this is all remembering that the IRP scheme provides no remedies for Charter violations, which means that the police get it wrong in law a lot more often. Only there’s nothing you can do about it.

What does my success look like?
As I mentioned, I work at the top IRP defence firm in the province. And I succeed in more IRP review hearings than any other lawyer on a month-by-month basis. There are benefits to immersing yourself in an area of law, understanding the science and technology behind the approved screening device breath tests, performing the calibration process, and being at the forefront of the most interesting legal challenges to this law.

So here are my numbers for each month:

  • May: 27 Immediate Roadside Prohibition cases revoked
  • June: 54 Immediate Roadside Prohibition cases revoked
  • July: 62 Immediate Roadside Prohibition cases revoked
  • August: 42 Immediate Roadside Prohibition cases revoked
  • September: 15 Immediate Roadside Prohibition cases revoked
  • October: 19 Immediate Roadside Prohibition cases revoked

Statistically, there is a benefit to calling our office and to hiring me to defend your Immediate Roadside Prohibition case. Our firm succeeds in more than any other law office, and often in more than all of the leading law offices combined. This isn’t manipulating statistics to show an unreliable number. You can see from the IRPs for which review hearings were conducted in each month that a significant percentage of overturned IRPs were clients of mine, each month.

I have been involved with the IRP scheme and challenges to BC’s DUI laws since the law was introduced. My success in these cases is evidence of the high degree of technical knowledge and training that I have when it comes to defending impaired driving and Immediate Roadside Prohibition cases. My firm has access to all of the calibration equipment, all the roadside breathalyzers used by police, and the manuals that police are trained on. Knowing the training, knowing the science, and knowing the process is what sets me apart.

If you’ve received an Immediate Roadside Prohibition and are wondering which law firm you should call for your best chance of success, it seems only reasonable to look at objective evidence. My track record with these cases is self-evident.

85 thoughts on “Immediate Roadside Prohibition for DUI: Success Rates and Statistics”

  1. I received a 90 day IRP 30 day vehicle impoundment on Sunday morning for failing to give an adequate breath test.
    If you could call me ASAP I would be grateful.
    778 558 9689

  2. In this context, it means doing something that makes you appear valuable — useful, insightful, entertaining, or interesting — to the blogger you’re aiming to woo. In other words, anything that establishes you as a person worth knowing and helps develop a personal relationship.
    Did a particular point in the post hit home for you? Did you find something particularly relatable? Did the post bring up an area in which you’re struggling?

  3. When you share a personal insight, bloggers can more easily relate to you. You’re no longer just an unfamiliar name making a comment that could have been left by anyone…
    Don’t worry about channeling Herman Melville; remember, comments don’t have to be long to be effective.

  4. Was an idea presented in the post that you didn’t fully understand? Did you want the author to expand on a certain point? Did the post spark an inquiry?
    You ask them a question; they answer. It’s pure, simple, poetry in motion. And it’s a great way to introduce yourself to bloggers you enjoy.

  5. Sometimes for brevity’s sake, an author won’t fully flesh out a detail in his or her blog post. So if the article contained a detail you want expanded upon, don’t be afraid to comment and ask.
    Were 10 ideas presented in the post, but you know an 11th? Want to flesh out a point discussed in the post? How about a detail that wasn’t covered at all?

  6. If your comments enhance the overall value of the post, few bloggers will fail to see the benefit of your contribution. Sometimes they’ll even update their post in light of your comment — which is a major validation of your ideas.
    The result is more people reading and discussing the blogger’s work, which means a higher comment count.

  7. How could a man who knew more torment and suffering by the age of 20 than I could begin to fathom in the darkest moments of my life, be a source of only happy memories? No one made me feel more loved, safe and indulged the specious struggles of my childhood with more concern and empathy.

  8. He experienced the pit of human evil and had every reason to be bitter and righteously angry for the rest of his life. But he didn’t. He loved fiercely, forgave completely. Now when I look back I can see why — it’s because he survived five years in concentration camps and was determined not to remain a prisoner.

  9. Around the world, Kobe was a cultural icon and a basketball megastar who spent 20 years playing for the Los Angeles Lakers, but for me, he’s a different person. For me, he will always be the guy who helped me launch my career at ESPN — without being asked and even though he was at the time just beginning his own basketball career.

  10. We were not personal friends and were never peers (I’m much older) — yet we were connected. Whenever I saw him on the road, there he was giving me the universal sign of respect, that silent black salute — the head nod. Just enough to command the respect in the room, and sometimes, the angry envy of my peers. I can never explain how much Kobe’s simple gestures of acknowledgment gave me the courage to compete in the sports media, where women are too often dismissed and even today, rarely recognized for their sports savvy and intelligence.

  11. Some of my colleagues didn’t know how to handle Kobe, many called him arrogant. Kobe was complicated to them. He didn’t come with a hard-luck story of growing up on tough streets. The son of Pam and Joe Bryant, the latter a former NBA player and WNBA coach, Kobe often seemed more worldly than many of the men covering and playing sports –which led to awkward conversations at news meetings on how to cover Kobe, both off and on the court.

  12. At summer basketball leagues, like the famous Holcombe Rucker Park in Harlem — where basketball games felt more like family reunions — I’d cross paths with Kobe. No one knew me in Harlem, I was a newcomer to New York. But Kobe always spotted me in the crowd standing there with my media pass hanging from my neck.

  13. Taking a few pieces and real
    effort to generate a great article … but what can I say … I
    putt things off a whole lot and don’t manage to get anything done.

    WOW just what I was looking for. Caame here by searching for.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Call Now ButtonCALL ME NOW Scroll to Top