Distracted Driving Tickets: You May Have a Valid Defence

January 31, 2022 / Blog
The Provincial Government clearly had good intentions when it made changes to the Motor Vehicle Act in 2010 to prohibit the use of personal electronic devices while operating a motor vehicle.

Barely 20 months after the legislation was introduced, Government had already tallied more than 46,000 tickets issued for distracted driving. Despite criticism from drivers, cell phone use while driving soon became a priority for law enforcement and legislators alike. It wasn’t entirely surprising. After all, distracted driving is a serious offence and can be a factor in crashes causing severe injury and death.
ICBC reports that approximately 78 people are killed each year in crashes “where driver inattention or distraction is a factor.” And as Government struggled to figure out how to get drivers to leave their phones alone, police conducted more and more enforcement blitzes with increasing vigilance.

Penalties have also doubled since the legislation was introduced. Initially, drivers caught using an electronic device were subject to a $167 ticket and three penalty points. Changes made in June last year increased the fine to $368 and added an additional penalty point.

This means a driver given a distracted driving ticket will now end up paying $543 in total for a first offence, when factoring in the increased premium for the extra penalty point.

What Does the Distracted Driving Legislation Actually Say?
The Government relies on the Motor Vehicle Act in its prosecution of distracted driving. The Act defines electronic devices to include not just cell phones, but also GPS devices, televisions, music players like iPods, and even voice recorders. Drivers are still allowed to use electronic devices while behind the wheel, but a criteria must be met.

For cell phones, this generally means using a hands-free device that’s either voice-activated or requires only one touch to start or end a call. A section in the regulation also requires drivers to “securely fix” their electronic devices to the vehicle in a way that doesn’t obstruct the driver.

Section 214.1 of the Act defines the “use” of an electronic device like so:

1. holding the device in a position in which it may be used;
2. operating one or more of the device’s functions;
3. communicating orally by means of the device with another person or another device;
4. taking another action that is set out in the regulations by means of, with or in relation to an electronic device.

There’s the Legislation, Then There’s the Reality
These days, simply taking a glance at a phone while behind the wheel may result in a ticket. It doesn’t matter if you’re texting at a red light, while idling in gridlock traffic, or even just plugging in your phone. Even if an officer isn’t certain that a phone is in use, such as in cases where you’re simply holding the phone without any intention to use the device, you may receive a ticket. Heck, police might pull you over even if you’ve followed the law in using your phone. It’s not always easy for police to tell from outside a vehicle exactly what the driver’s circumstances were.

Helpfully, two decisions from BC Courts have established that drivers may have viable defences when simply holding a cell phone, or having the phone loose and unsecured in a vehicle. In a case called R v. Chan, a Novice driver received a ticket just for having the device charging while placed in his vehicle’s cup holder. Novice drivers, under the Motor Vehicle Act, do not have the right to use a cell phone in any circumstances except for in an emergency. But the judge determined that simply charging the device does not constitute “using” the device. Moreover, the judge ruled the requirement for having a hands-free device “securely fixed” to a vehicle does not mean that a loose phone in a car is an automatic offence; regardless if the device was “in a cup holder, or laying on a passenger seat.”

In another phone-charging case, called R v. Jahani, the judge agreed with the driver’s argument that just holding a phone is not enough for a conviction. The judge concurred that “…the Motor Vehicle Act specifically provides that there must be holding and further an accompanying act” when defining whether an electronic device is in use. However, it’s worth pointing out that Mr. Jahani ultimately failed his appeal in the BC Supreme Court. Mr. Jahani admitted he was in the act of plugging his phone in when the officer pulled him over.

So Can I Hold the Phone or Have It Loose in the Car or Not?
What the two decisions demonstrate is that the courts allow a bit of leeway when it comes to how you’re holding your phone, and where you have it placed.

A distracted driving ticket’s validity can be suspect if, for example, you reach down to pick up a phone that fell near the brake pedal. Or perhaps, if you were just holding the phone to clean it, you might not necessarily be offending the law. Those circumstances would depend on how the phone was being held. Or let’s say you had both your phone and your cigarettes in the same cup holder, and a police officer issues a ticket after seeing you reach into the cup holder. Well, you might just have been reaching for a cigarette. Or maybe holding a phone that has sentimental value relieves your anxiety while you drive… who knows? Though in this case, you might need to consult a psychiatrist!

The point is, there can be many reasonable scenarios where someone appeared to be using a phone, but was actually doing no such thing. An experienced traffic ticket lawyer like myself can help distinguish those cases where the holding meets the definition of “use” under the Motor Vehicle Act, and those where it does not.

237 thoughts on “Distracted Driving Tickets: You May Have a Valid Defence”

  1. lawrence wong

    Hi Kyla,
    I literally had 2 tickets in the last 8 months.
    First ticket i took the phone out of my suit pocket and placed it on my passenger seat.
    The 2nd ticket I received today, my phone fell out of my charger near my gas and brake. i picked it up while traffic stopped on hwy one and tried plugging it back in.
    do you think i have grounds to dispute in any of these cases? The fines are really heavy…and in both cases im not talking, texting or anything..

  2. lawrence wong

    does it matter if i didnt tell the officer where it fell? i just said it fell and i was trying to plug it in

  3. lee's summit lawyer

    This is actually the kind of information I have been trying to find. Thank you for writing this information.

  5. Reet

    Hi actually my friend got ticket in june 2018 as because his phone felt down by the break pedal and he was grabbing his phone for safety reason but an officer gave him ticket and the fine is too much for him as he was not even using his phone, it just accidentally fell down.

  29. Bengal cats

    Wow! This could be one of the most useful blogs we have ever come across on thesubject. Actually excellent info! I’m also an expert in this topic so I can understand your effort.

  37. 토토

    What’s up to every one, the substance existing at this site are truly bewildering for. What I don’t fathomed is when in doubt how you’re not, now in all actuality considerably more adroitly appreciated than you might be right now. You’re so sharp. You see as needs be basically by virtue of this point, conveyed me as I would see it imagine it from such innumerable changed focuses. Its like women and men are excluded until it’s something to do with Lady insane! Your own stuffs outstanding. Reliably handle it up! What’s up it’s me, I am similarly visiting this site page each day, 토토

  43. Dr. Billa

    Our Mission; Provide appreciative solutions to all in need of RV Collision Repair, Paint, Body, Interior, & Upgrades, at a single Commercial Collision Repair Facility in Southern California! At OCRV Center, we take pride in providing everlasting, meaningful solutions for all commercial chassis owners. The moment you enter the facility, you will be acknowledged, heard & respected throughout the whole process of fulfilling & completing your requests. If you are seeking a competent, knowledgeable team of craftsmen & experts, OCRV Center proudly provides valuable solutions for all commercial chassis owners in Southern California! RV Body Shop Near Me

  44. Dr. Billa

    If you have any issue related to mywifiext.net then I am here with my technical team. You can visit our website and even speak to our technical support. mywifiext

  87. 슬롯머신

    Awesome dispatch! I am indeed getting apt to over this info, is truly neighborly my buddy. Likewise fantastic blog here among many of the costly info you acquire. Reserve up the beneficial process you are doing here.

  99. fia jobs

    Awesome article. I love your way of composing. It’s motivating and informative, please keep up the good work.The federal investigation agency is the Pakistani investigating department in the FIA Jobs is a border Control Criminal Investigation Security Agency & the counterintelligence is under the control of the interior factory of Pakistan. The Federal Investigation Agency (FIA) will be founded on 13 January 1975. The headquarter of the Federal Investigation Agency is located in Islamabad Pakistan. The present organization of Latest FIA Jobs 2022 is the Ministry of Interior and the Agency’s Executive is the Director-General. The Federal Investigation Agency (FIA) is the exclusive intelligence agency of Pakistan. The FIA is largely accountable for the enforcement of Pakistani laws & connected matters. It is also an investigative agency & brings up questions about crimes under Federal Laws.

  101. fahadhussain

    Acknowledges for penmanship such a worthy column, I stumbled beside your blog besides predict a handful advise. I want your tone of manuscript… Heist Stakes

  102. Satta king Online

    “Nice article. I truly like your content. It’s inspiring ,keep up the good work.Please go to my website. Satta king onlineYou don’t need to go around in search of an authentic website to play as we deliver original and genuine satta king online games for everyone. So, be relaxed when playing Delhi Satta King online and enjoy every bit of the game. We provide the best experience to all players and let them have fun while betting.
    “

  103. fahadhussain

    In this article understand the most important thing, the item will give you a keyword rich link a great useful website page: Pg slot 789

  105. fahadhussain

    In this article understand the most important thing, the item will give you a keyword rich link a great useful website page: agen777

  107. 호치민 카지노

    We are really grateful for your blog post. You will find a lot of approaches after visiting your post. I was exactly searching for. Thanks for such post and please keep it up. Great work.

  117. muhammad hasnain

    GO-PHOR is a fast, easy and affordable delivery app. It is Lyft or Uber for your stuff! From delivering important documents or a laptop with your work presentation to your office to picking up a new washer and dryer and delivering it to your doorstep, we do it all. GO-PHOR is your affordable personal messenger solution. If you forget to grab a tool at the hardware store and can’t leave your workspace in the middle of a project, use a GO-PHOR. Forgot your wallet? Have a GO-PHOR bring it to you. At just a dollar per mile and 25 cents a minute, anyone can afford to use it every day! home depot delivery Ellicot City

  126. fahadhussain

    In this article understand the most important thing, the item will give you a keyword rich link a great useful website page: 비트겟

  127. fahadhussain

    In this article understand the most important thing, the item will give you a keyword rich link a great useful website page: 바이낸스

  134. Satta result

    “There’re various types of Satta King 786 Games and every Satta company open different results at a different time of the day. These games are being played all over the world and the Satta result is the outcome that comes in the form of 2 digit numbers and opens it on a fixed time each day. Satta result is the Satta number that decides the winner of the Satta King Fast. You can all the Satta king result; their Satta result is well-arranged on each page as it’s a source of visitors to any website. You can see current and old Satta results, which can help you to bet on the next Satta game.Over a million people are playing Satta lottey game online across India. The money that players receive after winning is the most interesting aspect of this game. The winners are known as Satta King and the results are posted daily on our official website. Calculated risks can earn you big bucks with Satta Result. It is not necessary to invest a huge amount; you can also play with small money. The Satta game is quite easy to learn and play. Your win depends solely on your luck when you select the number randomly. Numbers must be chosen from 0 to 99. The game is risky but interesting. Gali Satta result, Diswar Satta Result, Faridabad result and Ghaziabad result are the 4 most searched keywords in Google. Several times the result gets leaked in the market which is known as the Satta leak number which can make you rich. Every Satta king 786 result was announced on time, as Disawar satta result announced at 5:10am, Gali Satta Result announced at 11:30 pm, Ghaziabad result was announced at 8:30 pm, And Faridabad result announce at 6:00 pm.,https://satta-king-786.info/
    “

  136. ashleymarsh

    Great, I want to say thank you for the information and articles you provided for us . The Kenya travel form is now available on online / Digital Platform. And you Can also apply for that form from anywhere and Anytime.

  137. fahadhussain

    Acknowledges for paper such a beneficial composition, I stumbled beside your blog besides decipher a limited announce. I want your technique of inscription… 바카라사이트

  138. 먹튀신고

    I’ve proper selected to build a blog, which I hold been deficient to do for a during. Acknowledges for this inform, it’s really serviceable!

  140. fahadhussain

    I’ve proper selected to build a blog, which I hold been deficient to do for a during. Acknowledges for this inform, it’s really serviceable! pgslot

  142. 다음드

    I’ve proper selected to build a blog, which I hold been deficient to do for a during. Acknowledges for this inform, it’s really serviceable!

  143. sam

    Thankyou Mr blogger. I appreciate your hard work on this great post .Vietnam visa validity depends on the type of visa which one you select. Here, all the information available for Vietnam evisa.

  145. 먹튀커뮤니티

    Initial You got a awesome blog .I determination be involved in plus uniform minutes. i view you got truly very functional matters , i determination be always checking your blog blesss.

  147. Muhammad Ali

    영화, 드라마, 예능 다시보기 사이트를 찾는 분을 위해서 방문하고자 하는 곳이 누누티비 또는 무비착이라면 언제든 접속하여 원하는 영화 뿐만 아니라 다양한 컨텐츠를 제공 받을 수 있습니다.
    드라마 다시보기

  152. fahadhussain

    On this subject internet page, you’ll see my best information, be sure to look over this level of detail. togel

  155. 홀덤

    I’ve proper selected to build a blog, which I hold been deficient to do for a during. Acknowledges for this inform, it’s really serviceable!

  162. fahadhussain

    I just thought it may be an idea to post incase anyone else was having problems researching but I am a little unsure if I am allowed to put names and addresses on here. keluaran sgp

  167. 먹튀검증업체

    I have to show my respect for your kindness in support of visitors who have the need for assistance with this important theme. Your real commitment to passing the solution up and down had been remarkably beneficial and have specifically made associates like me to arrive at their pursuits. Your important guidelines means a whole lot a person like me and substantially more to my office colleagues. Warm regards; from all of us. I simply needed to thank you so much once more. I’m not certain what I might have done without these solutions provided by you over such situation. It had been a real terrifying setting in my circumstances, however , understanding the skilled manner you dealt with it forced me to weep over contentment. Now i’m happier for the support and pray you know what a great job that you are doing educating most people all through your web blog. I am sure you’ve never got to know any of us. Thanks for sharing, this is a fantastic article.Thanks Again. Great. 먹튀검증업체

  169. 오래된토토사이트코드

    I’m just commenting to make you be aware of what a extraordinary encounter my friend’s child went through reading through your blog. She noticed so many issues, which included what it’s like to have an amazing teaching heart to have men and women quite simply fully grasp a variety of extremely tough topics. You truly exceeded our own expectations. I appreciate you for imparting the precious, dependable, informative and as well as cool tips about that topic to Emily. I precisely desired to thank you very much again. I’m not certain the things I could possibly have done in the absence of these solutions discussed by you concerning that subject. It was actually a very frightful circumstance in my position, but considering the well-written approach you processed it took me to weep with contentment. I’m thankful for the service and in addition have high hopes you are aware of a powerful job you are always putting in instructing the others thru your websites. More than likely you have never got to know all of us. 오래된토토사이트코드

  179. sievna

    Wow, It is really a very informative and interesting article. Do you know What is a cloud computing service is ? simply cloud computing service related to computer service like Data storage , networking , software. Data Management etc.

  190. win88

    I am really impressed with your writing style.Excellent Keep up the good work. win88 Indian horse race information is not always easy to come by and you can do your own research on the subject, but sometimes it can be difficult to find one online. If you want informative articles and guides on Indian horse races, then this article is for you!

  193. fahadhussain

    Acknowledges for penmanship such a worthy column, I stumbled beside your blog besides predict a handful advise. I want your tone of manuscript… guest post

  199. fahadhussain

    I just thought it may be an idea to post incase anyone else was having problems researching but I am a little unsure if I am allowed to put names and addresses on here. freelance

  200. fahadhussain

    I simply want to tell you that I am new to weblog and definitely liked this blog site. Very likely I’m going to bookmark your blog . You absolutely have wonderful stories. Cheers for sharing with us your blog. my website

  201. Satta king fast result

    I totally agree with this article. It’s inspiring and I absolutely like it. Please go to my website Satta king fast result You don’t need to go around in search of an authentic website to play as we deliver original and genuine satta king online games for everyone. So, be relaxed when playing Satta King online and enjoy every bit of the game. We provide the best experience to all players and let them have fun while betting.

  205. fahadhussain

    I just thought it may be an idea to post incase anyone else was having problems researching but I am a little unsure if I am allowed to put names and addresses on here. click to find out more

  213. ashleymarsh

    I think the administrator of this site is really buckling down for his post , on the grounds that all the substance here is quality based. What is an India electronic visa? It is a permit for foreigners to visit India for many purposes.

  219. fahadhussain

    Initial You got a awesome blog .I determination be involved in plus uniform minutes. i view you got truly very functional matters , i determination be always checking your blog blesss. japandi style

  222. 로미로미

    I just thought it may be an idea to post incase anyone else was having problems researching but I am a little unsure if I am allowed to put names and addresses on here.

  227. fahadhussain

    Awesome dispatch! I am indeed getting apt to over this info, is truly neighborly my buddy. Likewise fantastic blog here among many of the costly info you acquire. Reserve up the beneficial process you are doing here. video-stock

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Contact Kyla Lee for a

FREE CONSULTATION

Twitter Facebook Instagram Youtube

215 – 114 East 7th Ave. Vancouver, BC V5T 1M6
604-685-8889
kyla@kylalee.ca

Design by Brazen Bull Creative Inc

@ Copyright 2022- All Rights Reserved

Scroll to Top
Call Now ButtonCALL ME NOW